Pinterest tracking pixel
If you are having difficulty navigating this website please contact us at accessibility@bookofthemonth.com or 1-833-959-2686.
Oops! The page didn’t load right. Please refresh and try again.
All booksThrillerMissing, Presumed
Missing, Presumed by Susie Steiner
Thriller

Missing, Presumed

by Susie Steiner

Quick take

Every cast member is full of surprises. All of them have secrets...My suspicions kept shifting as I read.

Why I love it

Maud Newton
Writer

A beautiful young Cambridge grad named Edith Hind, vanishes from her house on a snowy winter night, leaving behind her cell phone, her keys, her coat, a broken wine glass, and some drops of blood. Surely the culprit must be her handsome boyfriend? Or, her needy best friend? Or, the affable cold-blooded killer just out of prison? Or?

One tantalizing thing about Missing, Presumed is that the mystery feels as though it should be easy to solve. It's a hard whodunnit to puzzle out. The author embeds clues in intricate psychological portraits of each of her characters. Every cast member is full of surprises. All of them have secrets and most are characters prone to telling half-truths. My suspicions kept shifting as I read.

Our hero—the reader's best hope for a satisfying resolution to the case—is Manon, a smart, lonely, bitingly funny detective with Scotland Yard. Manon navigates the stress, bureaucracy, and cafeteria meals of her job to solve some of the agency's most vexing mysteries, and spends her free time going on terrible internet dates.

Although Edith is offstage as the plot develops, Manon's dogged and deft investigation allows us to develop a portrait of the missing woman: clever, earnest, and spoiled, a little dramatic and a little self-dramatizing, capable of immense selfishness and endearing kindness, of callousness and tremendous feeling. The characters' competing perspectives on Edith and her motives keep the story speeding forward. The many false leads along the way add to the excitement.

Ultimately, the beauty of this book is less about plot than about its insights into unexpected connections between people. Whatever resolutions the characters may find by the end of the book are not the kind they've been seeking—or the kind we're expecting.

Touches like these elevate Missing, Presumed far beyond a boilerplate police procedural into a work of art. Weeks after I finished reading I still find myself thinking—wondering—about the characters. And hoping for a sequel.

Read less

Member thoughts

All (1343)
All (1343)
Love (287)
Like (779)
Dislike (277)
1405 ratings
  • 20% Love
  • 55% Like
  • 20% Dislike
  • Westbrook , ME

    Susie Steiner is a phenomenal author and the police procedure of this novel is the backdrop to a powerful story about the expectations placed on women. Fantastic writing and nuanced characters. Loved.

  • Tulsa, OK

    A pleasant surprise this book turned out to be! I've had many good reads this year and this one definitely reminded me how much I enjoy a well-rendered, character-driven police novel. Great read!

  • Owasso, OK

    This book was very slow for me at first, but at one point something snapped in me and I could not put it down! I was very surprised when I found out what had actually happened to Edith. Great read!

  • Oklahoma City, OK

    This book made me think of Sherlock Holmes, while also bringing me back to reality with the descriptions of the life of Manon - I related to her because of her determination to do what is right.

  • Ypsilanti, MI

    It's rare to stumble upon a police procedural as well-written as Susie Steiner has created with this book. Reminiscent of Tana French, the characters will stay with me long after I finished.

  • Minot, ND

    Who would've predicted such an ending?! I generally struggle with different POVs, but the transitions were so smooth I hardly noticed. Great read, crazy twists and neat characters.

  • spokane, WA

    The different storytellers made a good plot even better. It was modern, twisted, and altogether brilliant. This will have a permanent place on my bookshelf for sure. Love this book.

  • bloomington, CA

    Great book! Touched your heart strings a bit and I love reading books that come from authors in different countries other than the US. I love learning new words and language.

  • Charlottesville, VA

    This was my first BOTM, and I’m so glad I joined, because I wouldn’t have been aware of this author otherwise. Remineded me of Tana French, one of my favorite authors.

  • Indianapolis, IN

    Loved this book. Wish it went on a bit more after it ended, but it was wonderful all the same. Page turner and just couldn't wait to get to the end to see what happened.

  • North Hollywood, CA

    A page-turning mystery with excellently drawn characters. Nothing groundbreaking in terms of the prose or style, but a perfectly serviceable who-dunnit with a twist.

  • Lilburn, GA

    Steiner keeps you guessing in this novel! Plenty of twists and an interesting ending make you feel like you know the what's going to happen... until it doesn't.

  • Syracuse, NY

    This was a great book that follows a police officer in the UK as she looks for a missing woman. I read this and the sequel very quickly. Highly recommend!

  • Alpena, MI

    I loved reading this! I could not set it down. The ending throws you for a loop. I love the detective, too. Her character was genuine and well developed.

  • Bakersfield, CA

    A great book with a mystery that keeps growing and unfolding. Seemingly little clues that had nothing to do with each other came together in a big way

  • Little Falls, NY

    I couldn't put this book down! The way the different characters were connected was so intricately written that it left for an unexpected ending.

  • Rockville Centre, NY

    I really enjoyed this book. Great characters and a little something for everyone! Mystery, crime, love, break ups, and a good ending!

  • South Pittsburg , TN

    This was a well-written mystery. I loved reading from the different point of views. It aided in keeping me guessing the whole time!

  • Washington, DC

    Slow at the beginning, but beautiful writing and the reveal at the end make the book worth reading. Looking forward to the sequel!

  • Coarsegold, CA

    This was an excellent mystery with a strong female lead. It was fast paced with interesting characters and a satisfying ending.

Thriller
  • The Maidens
  • Not a Happy Family
  • Razorblade Tears
  • The Last Thing He Told Me
  • The Wife Upstairs
  • Too Good to Be True
  • The Push
  • The Last Flight
  • 56 Days
  • The Damage
  • Rock Paper Scissors
  • Survive the Night
  • The Woman in the Window
  • The Hunting Party
  • The Silent Patient
  • Goodnight Beautiful
  • Winter Counts
  • The Hunting Wives
  • Pretty Little Wife
  • The Guest List
  • Invisible Girl
  • Girl A
  • Behind Her Eyes
  • The Girl in the Mirror
  • The Night Swim
  • Before She Knew Him
  • Then She Was Gone
  • You Are Not Alone
  • Sharp Objects
  • The Family Upstairs
  • The Wife Between Us
  • Into the Water
  • Gone Girl
  • Dark Places
  • The Alienist
  • Since We Fell
  • The Blinds
  • Cross Her Heart
  • The Chestnut Man
  • The Winter Sister
  • The Other Woman
  • Necessary People