Pinterest tracking pixel
If you are having difficulty navigating this website please contact us at accessibility@bookofthemonth.com or 1-833-959-2686.
Oops! The page didn’t load right. Please refresh and try again.
All booksThrillerWhat She Knew
What She Knew by Gilly Macmillan
Thriller

What She Knew

Debut
We love supporting debut authors. Congrats, Gilly Macmillan, on your first book!

by Gilly Macmillan

Quick take

Macmillan keeps the tension building—this is an up-til-3-am kind of read—without skimping on substance or character development.

Why I love it

Kim Hubbard
People Magazine

Thrillers aren't my go-to genre, but there's a certain kind of crime drama—British, psychologically nuanced, helmed by a damaged, sexy P.I.—that never fails to put me in its thrall. Think Kate Atkinson's Case Histories or ITV's Broadchurch (and if you haven't had the pleasure in either case, fix that now). I wasn't expecting this debut to meet my standards, but boy does What She Knew deliver.

The event that sets the story in motion is enough to still any parent's heart: on a walk in the woods near Bristol with his divorced mom, Rachel, 8-year-old Ben Finch begs to run ahead to their favorite rope swing. Rachel nervously agrees because "in the absence of Ben's dad I thought it was my responsibility to…encourage Ben to be independent, to take risks, to discover life." The empty, still-swaying swing she sees when she arrives tells her she made the wrong call.

In the nightmare days that follow, DI James Clemo (sexy, damaged) battles the clock to find Ben. As the odds that Ben has survived diminish, Rachel finds herself questioning not just her own judgment, but everything and everyone. Is her "mother-of-the-year" sister Nicky uncomplicatedly devoted—or hiding devastating secrets? Could her best friend Laura be feeding information to the ravenous press? Is maternal instinct her best friend, or will it invariably lead her astray? Detective Clemo seems devastated by the case on a deeply personal level. But why?

As Rachel's version of events alternates with Detective Clemo's, Gilly Macmillan keeps the tension building—this is an up-til-3-am kind of read—without stinting on substance or character development. Like any violent disruption, Ben's disappearance strips away pretenses and crumbles the facades of those affected. "Are any of our… relationships really based on secure foundations?" Rachel wonders. By the end of this gripping, insightful novel, you'll be wondering that yourself.

Read less

Member thoughts

All (181)
All (181)
Love (64)
Like (108)
Dislike (9)
188 ratings
  • 34% Love
  • 57% Like
  • 5% Dislike
  • Reno, NV

    I enjoyed this book and trying to figure out the mystery. It had a good pace and interesting plot. I thought the inclusion of social media was an novel take.

  • Lexington, KY

    I read it all in one sitting. Once I started reading I was hooked, and couldn't stop until it was finished.

  • SAMMAMISH, WA

    Great read, and kept me on my toes! Definitely recommend this to anyone who loves a good mystery.

  • Amarillo, TX

    I really enjoyed this one and have since read it again! One of the best mysteries of the year.

  • Lacey, WA

    Hard to read as a parent but it's incredible. I bought another copy as a present to someone.

  • San Francisco, CA

    One of the best mysteries I read in 2016. Fans of Gone Girl should flock to this book.

  • Chesapeake , VA

    This book had me guessing all the way to the end! Great read with an awesome author!

  • Chicago, IL

    Loved, can't wait to read more by this author!

  • Hutchinson , KS

    I finished this book in a matter of days!!!

  • Cincinnati, OH

    Loved it! Kept me guessing until the end!

  • Dalton, GA

    Kept me guessing

  • Lancaster, CA

    Really good!

  • San Francisco, CA

  • Ballston Spa, NY

  • Glencoe, AL

  • Rochester, MN

  • Chelmsford, MA

  • San Diego, CA

  • Cambridge, MA

  • West Des Moines, IA

Thriller
  • The Maidens
  • Not a Happy Family
  • Razorblade Tears
  • The Last Thing He Told Me
  • The Wife Upstairs
  • Too Good to Be True
  • The Push
  • The Last Flight
  • 56 Days
  • The Damage
  • Rock Paper Scissors
  • Survive the Night
  • The Woman in the Window
  • The Hunting Party
  • The Silent Patient
  • Goodnight Beautiful
  • Winter Counts
  • The Hunting Wives
  • Pretty Little Wife
  • The Guest List
  • Invisible Girl
  • Girl A
  • Behind Her Eyes
  • The Girl in the Mirror
  • The Night Swim
  • Before She Knew Him
  • Then She Was Gone
  • You Are Not Alone
  • Sharp Objects
  • The Family Upstairs
  • The Wife Between Us
  • Into the Water
  • Gone Girl
  • Dark Places
  • The Alienist
  • Since We Fell
  • The Blinds
  • Cross Her Heart
  • The Chestnut Man
  • The Winter Sister
  • The Other Woman
  • Necessary People